Food Industry Coalition Files Lawsuit Against Soda Ban

Oct 15, 2012 01:22 AM EDT | By Sharon Robinson

  • print
Large Sodas
A poster by 7/11, which aims to save the Big Gulp, a large soda. If Mayor Bloomberg's plan goes well, the Big Gulp and other large sodas will be phased out. (Photo : flickr.com/ Mike Licht, NotionsCapital.com)

The soda industry filed a lawsuit to block New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg's decision to ban all sodas bigger than 16-ounces. The American Beverage Association, as predicted, sued in the New York State Supreme Court, to prevent the law from being implemented.

Bloomberg, with the support of the Health Advisory Board, passed the rule which bans sodas larger than 16-ounces from theatres, restaurants, stadiums and arenas. It was a step toward bringing down obesity rates in the city. More than half the population of New York is obese and a third is overweight.

Like Us on Facebook

The rule is set to take effect in March 2013.

The decision, however, was met with widespread opposition from food businesses in the city and from consumers. Bloomberg has been accused of running a "nanny state," where he dictates what the citizens can eat or drink.

"The ban at issue in this case burdens consumers and unfairly harms small businesses at a time when we can ill afford it," said the coalition of food businesses, according to a report in Bloomberg. "Defendants do not have the legal authority to adopt this beverage ban, and it is arbitrary and capricious in its design and application."

The food industry claims that Bloomberg only appointed those members in the Health Advisory Board who were bound to support the ban. The panel consisted mostly of health experts and doctors. The Health Department too has been accused of overstepping its authority. They also believe that sales of sodas are likely to go down following the implementation of this rule.

"The Board of Health absolutely has the authority to regulate matters affecting health, and the obesity crisis killing nearly 6,000 New Yorkers a year -- and impacting the lives of thousands more -- unquestionably falls under its purview," Marc LaVorgna, a spokesman for the mayor, said in a statement, according to the New York Times.

He further adds that the lawsuit is "baseless" and will only put the obesity epidemic in the spotlight.

According to the Associated Press, Bloomberg believes that removing large sodas from the market will keep people from consuming extra calories and "is a reasonable way to fight obesity."

"Nobody is banning anything," the mayor said when the plan passed, noting that someone who wanted a second soda could get one, reports AP.

The American Beverage Association is supported by the American Restaurant Association and the National Association of Theatre Owners of New York State.

 

 

© 2014 Food World News. All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.
Get the Most Popular Food Stories in a Weekly Newsletter
TrendingOn The Web
Food Biz
US food Homepage

Sysco In Talks With FTC To Save US Foods Deal

Food distributor Sysco Corp's executives are in talks with the U.S. Federal Trade Commission to salvage the company's attempt to buy its smaller rival US Foods Inc, the New York Post reported.

Food Shopping

Top Health Food Trends This Year

The year 2014 is all about healthy dining. Our reporters were on the ground for the top health food trends for the year.

Community Takes Legal Action Against Sriracha Hot Sauce Factory Over Chile Scent In Air

Taco Bell Sriracha Menu Is Here

Spice Lovers Can Try It Out Now … Starting In The Kansas City Area!

Food Tech
Red Cross workers distribute food at a World Food Programme storage center in Monrovia October 16, 2014.

Food Prices Up 24 Percent In Ebola-Hit Countries

Food prices have risen by an average of 24 percent across the three countries worst hit by the Ebola outbreak, forcing some families to reduce their intake to one meal a day, the World Food Program (WFP) said on Friday.

A new study by Louisiana State University researchers suggests that drinking two glasses of Tart Cherry Juice daily can help increase your sleeping time by about 90 minutes at night.

Improve your Sleep and Get Rid of Insomia with Tart Cherry Juice

Do you struggle to sleep for hours or do you wake up in the middle of the night and ends up wide awake until it's already time for you to get up?

A member of the CG Environmental HazMat team disinfects the entrance to the residence of a health worker at the Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital who has contracted Ebola in Dallas, Texas, October 12, 2014.

Read This To Get A Better Understanding Of How Ebola Spreads

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention confirmed Sunday that a nurse at a Dallas hospital who cared for Thomas Eric Duncan, who died from Ebola last week, was the first person to become infected with the virus on U. S. soil.

Real Time Analytics